Baltimore, OH Listings Local Resources Dining Shopping Leisure Highest Rated Dining Weidner's Corner 2 $ 22 reviews Bars, Diners (740) 400-5023 8010 Lancaster-Newark RdBaltimore, OH 43105 Baltimore Pint House $$ 57 reviews American, Bars (740) 400-4548 108 N Main StBaltimore, OH 43105 Papito's Kitchen $ 44 reviews Seafood (740) 400-5026 101 N Basil StBaltimore, OH 43105 The Farmhouse Cafe $ 7 reviews American, Breakfast & Brunch, Diners (740) 862-3016 201 W Market StBaltimore, OH 43105 Schaffner's Drive In $ 33 reviews Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Fast Food (740) 862-6832 601 W Market StBaltimore, OH 43105 Hereinafter Cocktail Tavern $ 53 reviews Cocktail Bars, Cajun/Creole, Breakfast & Brunch (740) 467-6440 3430 N Bank RdMillersport, OH 43046 Sis & Harold's Pizza $ 8 reviews Pizza (740) 862-4998 116 N Basil StBaltimore, OH 43105 Fillin’ Station $ 33 reviews Bars, American (740) 756-9995 76 Center StCarroll, OH 43112 Chef Shack $ 52 reviews American (740) 822-0011 5176 Walnut RdBuckeye Lake Brewery Island House $$ 31 reviews American, Diners, Salad (740) 467-2035 2977 Greenlawn AveMillersport, OH 43046 Cherry Street Pub $$ 478 reviews Pubs, American (740) 654-7828 202 N Cherry StLancaster, OH 43130 Osteria Alla Romana $$ 66 reviews Pizza, Italian, Salad (740) 785-9154 1453 Tiki LnLancaster, OH 43130 Our Lakeside Diner $ 18 reviews Diners (740) 928-4062 5276 Walnut RdBuckeye Lake, OH 43008 The Canal Mexican Grill $ 13 reviews Mexican (740) 467-2514 12045 Lancaster StMillersport, OH 43046 Cristy's Pizza $ 16 reviews Pizza, Salad, Sandwiches (740) 862-6611 1001 S Main StSte 12 Ale House 1890 $$ 271 reviews American, Bars, Venues & Event Spaces (740) 277-6053 149 W Main StLancaster, OH 43130 Hometown Hot Dogs $ 80 reviews Hot Dogs, Sandwiches (740) 467-1310 12031 Lancaster St NEMillersport, OH 43046 Castaways $$$ 36 reviews American, Seafood, Steakhouses (740) 337-0207 1500 N High StLancaster, OH 43130 Olde Canal Restaurant $ 10 reviews Fast Food (740) 467-2514 12045 Lancaster St NEMillersport, OH 43046 Buckeye Lake Margaritas $ 18 reviews Mexican, Salad, Cocktail Bars (740) 822-0003 4675 Walnut RdBuckeye Lake, OH 43008 Beach House Pub $$ 9 reviews Sports Bars, American (740) 467-7180 13574 Shell Beach RdThornville, OH 43076 JB's Downtown Grill $$ 71 reviews Burgers, New American, Diners (740) 422-8422 111 N Columbus StLancaster, OH 43130 Shirkys Pizza Zone $$ 54 reviews Pizza (740) 756-9663 70 E Canal StCarroll, OH 43112 Todds Mountain View Restaurant $ 117 reviews American, Breakfast & Brunch, Sandwiches (740) 653-5973 540 W Fair AveLancaster, OH 43130 Taqueria El Tapatio $ 42 reviews Mexican, Seafood (740) 422-8017 1021 N Memorial DrLancaster, OH 43130